Desserts for Any Occassion!
The Sweet Tooth makes all of our desserts from scratch. We offer a plethora of various cakes, pies, cookies and candy. You may come in during our regular business hours, call to request an appointment/order or fill out the form below. Whether you want to syop into our cozy cafe to satisfy your sweet tooth, or take a dessert home with you, we cater to your craving!
Cakes
The Sweet Tooth offers several cakes each day for you to sample by the slice as a bit of a mid-day snack or a delectible dessert. Each day is a little different, so the cakes we have on hand vary slightly. But here are some of the more typical cakes we have available:
- Red Velvet - Tangy, light chocolate, deep red color. A Southern classic!
- Hummingbird - Moist with lots of fresh banana flavor. Banana, pineapple, and pecans.
- Cheese Cake - One of many variations on a classic.
- Italian Cream - Light and soft. An old family recipe with coconut, and pecans.
- Seriously Chocolate - Dark dense chocolate.
- Carrot - Super moist and spicy! Fresh shredded carrots, pineapple, coconut, and walnuts.
- Elvis - Moist banana cake with pineapple and chocolate chips.
- Coconut - Soft coconut cake.
- Buttermilk - An old fashioned yellow cake with a dense texture.
- Chocolate Chip - A soft yellow cake with chocolate chips and a light almond flavor.
- Strawberry - A soft moist cake with bits of strawberry in the batter with a beautiful pink color.
You may order any of the above cakes to take home for yourself. We make more types of cakes than we can list, but you can view a slew of suggestions, sizes and pricing by downloading our Cake Combinations PDF here.
Pies
We also have a choice selection of pies available to sample by the slice. All our pies are made with either a butter pie crust or a crumb crust. Stop by to taste one of the following pies that we may have available:
- Coconut cream
- Chocolate Cream
- Pony
- Summer Berry
- Peanut Butter
- Harvest Apple
- Apple Streusel
- Key West Key Lime
- Pecan Pie
- Shaker Lemon
- Pumpkin Pie
You may order any of the above pies to take home or to a friend. All our Pies are just $20. Order one today by calling us at (502)895-4554, or fill out the form below!
Cookies
Every day, we have plenty of cookies sure to 'cater to your craving.' From our classic Chocolate Chip Cookie, to the popular Healthy Cookie (it really is healthy, we promise), to our Chocolate-dipped Macaroons... you'll want to try them all. Here are some more options:
- Callebaut-Belgian Chocolate Chunk
- Cranberry Almond Oatmeal (as featured in the Courier Journal)
- Lemon tea
- Snickerdoodle
- Super Spice - oatmeal, raisins, secret spice blend
- Oatmeal Chocolate Chunk
- Ganache Brownie
- Caramel Blondie
- Pecan Bar
- Oatmeal Cream Pies
- Chocolate Dipped Macaroons
- Decorated Sugar
Cookies also make great gifts, and you may order any of the above by the dozen to take home or to surprise a friend. Order today by calling us at (502)895-4554, or fill out the form below!
Candy
For the smaller taste buds, or those of you refusing to grow up, we have an array of candy to tide you over. A particular favorite is our White-Chocolate Covered Pretzel Sticks. But we have much more than that:
- Bourbon Balls (Christmas, Derby & special order only)
- Peanut Butter Balls
- Turtles
- White Chocolate Pretzels
- Espresso Bark
- Peanut Butter Bars
- S'mores
- Peppermint Bark
You may order any of the above candy in various amounts (gift boxes too). We make custom and seasonal sugar cookies too. Order one today by calling us at (502)895-4554, or fill out the form below!
Order Today!
We appreciate you visiting us online. Please, fill out the form below to request an order for any of our desserts. We will contact you regarding your request. We can get very busy, but will contact you as soon as possible. Thank you!
Thank you again for your order. You can also call us at (502)895-4554, or just stop by.
